Thursday, March 09, 2006

Liam Markus. part 2

Thank you Liam for commenting on my blog and setting the record straight. I'd like to ask you however if you believe that you are an exception to the rule or if you know of other donor offsprings who share your point of view ?

I've also wondered if DC girls were more likely to have "identity problems" rather than DC boys and interestingly enough I found an article on the net this afternoon that makes a reference to it for which you will find an exerpt bellow.

The article was written by
Dr. Vivienne Adair
Director, Centre for Child and family Policy Research
Senior Lecturer, School of Education

"Identities are forged by a combination of the past, present and the future and it is here that parents of children who have a conception using donor gametes have a special set of variables to contend with. As knowing oneself depends to some extent on knowing where one comes from, there may be different stresses and tasks to accomplish. It is always tempting to look to adoption as a comparison, but the situation has important differences. With assisted reproductive technology (ART) there is no ‘giving away’ of a child and donors have been encouraged to view gametes as ‘body parts’ by the donors, rather than as a prospective living child. The second difference is that semen and/or eggs have been produced specifically for recipient parents.

However, there are similarities for the child especially in the middle and late teenage years. The similarities are around the need for information about genetic background. For those teenagers who have a knowledge of the involvement of a donor in their conception, the interest in who they are seems to begin from about 13 years of age. Some want information about the donor at this stage and some want to meet him whether or not that is possible. There is not enough information to make definitive statements about this, but it appears that boys may be less likely to want to meet a donor than girls and that older more than younger teenagers want information. As well, it appears that acceptance of having no information or possible contact is dealt with differently. It would take an indepth study to determine which characteristics lead to acceptance and which do not, and at this point no such study has been undertaken."


http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/afrc6papers/adair.html


posted by MAX at 7:19 PM

1 Comments:

Blogger DI_Dad said...

Lia -

To say that DD's initial reference to Liam's comments on the (radio?) show was a "cheap and nasty" move is illogical. DD as a potential DI Dad has a right to want to know if there are DC people out there who are happy in their life without being overtaken with the issues surrounding their conception. To make reference to one such person in comparison to the many instances that you refer to is legitamate and to say otherwise to devalue his thought processes and right to freedom of expression and speach.

Your comments to Liam that his views trivialize the pain of others surprise me as well. As I thought I read that he recognizes these are his own views and not perhaps the views of others. To say his statements trivialize others again devalues his worth and again unfair.

In each of these points you are twisting the presentation of these men's views to get out your own message and again that is not discussion it's someone yelling with the goal of obscuring another's freedom of speach.

- Eric

10 March, 2006 01:13  

Post a Comment

<< Home

About Me

My Photo
Name: MAX
Location: Sydney, Australia

The way it is

View my complete profile

Click on banner to see who supports this initiative

Infertility Bloggers

  • Di-dad
  • Di-dad speak out
  • Di-dad yahoo group
  • End of my line
  • Malefactor
  • Dadsomeday
  • New consumer model

    Infertility Bloggettes

  • The sweet life
  • Stella&Ben
  • Ivfandicsi
  • Going it alone
  • Infertile fantasies
  • Journey to the centre
  • Live a little
  • The Towncriers

    Mixed Links

    • Australian news
    • TOG
    • worth1000
    • Imagenetion
    • Zazz
    • Thievery Corp
    • DeviantArt
    www.flickr.com
    This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from moonmax06. Make your own badge here.

    Previous Posts

    • Consequences of naming known donor on Birth Certif...
    • Going Dental
    • Biological malfunction
    • Jet lag
    • Eye Candy.
    • A question of taste.
    • Liam Markus
    • Digital art
    • Catch 22
    • Co - parenting

    Powered by Blogger